Ten Essentials to build your own Cozy Murder Mystery Kit

Posted November 29, 2022 by elzaread in Top Ten Tuesday / 54 Comments

 Greetings you guys!  It’s Tuesday and time for Top Ten Tuesday – the one stability we currently have. Thank you Jana! Today’s prompt is all about cozy reads. If we see the word cozy, we immediately think –murder mystery! My Mommy only started reading cozy mysteries about a year ago and she’s as hooked as a well crocheted blanked.

For today, we will tweak the prompt a bit and instead of talking about cozy mysteries, we are going to show you how you can build your very own Cozy Murder Mystery kit. We’ve used a few of these in a Friday Fives post in September last year, so we are just going to add a few more essentials.

If you can combine these ten elements and have a good murder in mind, you can write the next best seller!

1. The Female of the species takes center stage

Your leading character should most probably be a woman. A retired school teacher, a librarian, the town’s beloved spinster, a receptionist at the doctor’s office. These days women can be whatever they want to be, so figure out that murder and place your female sleuth right in the center. Bonus points if she stumble over or upon the dead body. Everytime.

2. A small town / Seaside Town / The Countryside

The ideal setting for a Cozy Murder Mystery, is key. Everybody has to know each other. Your amateur sleuth, who will of course be the crime solver extraordinaire and the main character for the rest of your series, is also not allowed to be a complete stranger. She has to be a long lost relative, or the beneficiary of a forgotten will at least.


3. An Inheritance

Your sleuth has to end up in Little Town for a reason. An inheritance is a sure win. Oh your options are endless! Your sleuth can inherit an old house (first prize winner all the time), a shop (bookshops are also good to guarantee a 5 star read), a bakery, an inn, or even the whole town! let your imagination run free. Just remember, there has to space to hide a body and a whole collection of Clue characters that are all rather suspicious. Note: It’s never, ever one of the suspicious characters. Rather kill them off if you don’t like them, but don’t let them be the killer.



4. A Cat
Your amateur sleuth is moving to the Little Town all by herself. She is either divorced, widowed or unluckily single. She will need company and a crime-solving partner who is non-human. Your ideal option  is a cat. The occasional dog can work too, but only in very, very rare circumstances. You can decide if the kitty moves with, if it’s going to be a rescue kitty (always a sure heart-warmer), or if the kitty is part of the inheritance. You are of course welcome to use more than one feline character. Just never kill them off. Being kidnapped or very slightly hurt, is acceptable and brings a lovely twist in the tail tale.



5. A Gossip Club 
You will need a communal area for gossip. A place where you can pick up all the “my uncle’s nephew’s first wife’s, second cousin once removed’s, daughter in law’s, cat with the seven kittens” stories. Both killer and/or murder victim are usually a member, or a loyal patron. Even if it’s only for a short while. Once again, the opportunities are endless. A coffeeshop, a library, a book club, a wine club, a knitting club, a crochet club, a quilting club, a tennis club, a murder club etc. They just have to meet at least once a month and there must be some juicy gossip. Usually regarding the stranger in town. Note: That stranger is 9/10 times the killer. Or the murder victim.

6. A Romantic Interest

One of the key difference between a Murder Mystery and a Cozy Murder Mystery, is that the Cozy Murder Mystery normally ends with a warm and cozy feeling. No better way to generate that than with a romantic interest. This love interest is normally someone on the side of the law. Your sleuth’s main purpose is to solve murders. But that is not her job, she and her feline partner are just so clever and witty to solve all the murders. She still needs someone with a badge or a degree or something relevant to do the final paperwork. Yes, a love triangle is allowed and you can stretch this out way into your series.


7. A Paranormal element 

If you are going for the old house inheritance, why not throw in a ghost? It can either be a long-ago murder victim that you can tie up with the latest murder, or a ghost who is there to help you solve the murder. If ghosts are not your thing (they sure are ours), how about witches? Your sleuth can be the descendent from an original Salem witch and her family secretly rules the whole town. Magical realism is becoming more popular in cozies every day!

8. Remove the gag-factor

A good murder mystery/thriller can sometimes be very gruesome with lots of dark and upsetting scenes. Some of the characters swear like a sailor walking the plank and the intimate scenes tend to shock rather than sooth. You want to remove all of these elements from your cozy  murder mystery. As much as the female sleuth takes center stage, as much must the gag factors remain in the wings. Intimate scenes can have a lights fade softly element.


9. Laughter is always the best medicine


Don’t make your female sleuth the town clown, but a town clown is always good for a few laughs. Remember what I’ve said, the idea of a cozy is to leave you with warm fuzzy feelings and forget about the dead guy as soon as you close the book. A funny cat and her crazy antics are always a good idea for the town clown. Or a quirky character that always makes the sleuth and the rest of the town giggle about how she dresses, talks or treat her dog. In cozies, no ones feelings get hurt. I promise. Think Angela Lansbury. Not as Jessica Fletcher, but as Salome Otterbourne.


10. A Recipe Guide

A sure way to make sure your readers are going to buy the second book in your series as well, is to include a few home-made recipes. Readers love that. And no, your sleuth doesn’t have to be the maker of the delicious dishes, it can be the town clown. Or even the murder victim. Fun twist – the victim was killed for her recipe book.  We love books with recipes added to the back, my Mommy has even tried a few!

And there you have it. Ten easy essentials to put you on the path to writing your own Cozy Murder Mystery. Now, go and find yourself a murder with an interested plot and use our ready made kit. We promise we will be the first to read it!
Share the Meows
Follow by Email
Visit Us
Follow Me

54 responses to “Ten Essentials to build your own Cozy Murder Mystery Kit

  1. Love this! Inheritance is one of my favorite aspects of cozies though I tend to prefer dogs then cats as the animal sidekick (sorry Elza!).

  2. This is a great list. Cats are essential. they just OOZE mystery, right? Love the Big Book, by the way. Looks awesome and I’ve seen it somewhere and wanted to get it. I love a good spooky element also. Ooh and recipes! Yes I know this is probably surprisng but I’ve read a few cozies with recipes and yes please! They make me hungry for sure, but then I never end up actually trying any of them.

    Greg recently posted: Tuesday Tagline #
    • Hi Greg!

      Yes, of course cats need to be the main characters in cozy mysteries. I think it’s time for me to start writing my own! LOL!!

      Cozies aren’t a genre that’s very popular here in SA. Perhaps our crime rates are just too high to justify a cozy murder setting. BUT if I can recommend a brilliant cozy murder mystery set in SA that comes with delicious recipes, it will be Recipes for Love and Murder by Sally Andrew. I’m sure you will enjoy it.

      Thanks for the visit Greg and so sorry for the late replies lately. Have a good week ahead!

    • Hi there Terrie!

      I never read cozies and got a few for review during the last two years and now I quite enjoy them. Although I still prefer my more hardcore murder mystery/thriller. This is a genre we don’t have a lot of books of in Afrikaans! Perhaps because South Africa doesn’t quite have a good setting for cozy murders….

      I am going to take a look at the Giraffe book! I have added it to my TBR!

      Thanks for the visit and sorry for the late reply!

  3. Excellent! (This could work for Wondrous Words, too, I dare say…)

    We needed this post last year at this time when we decided to read “a cozy mystery” for Christmas and nobody knew what a cozy mystery was!

    Deb Nance at Readerbuzz recently posted: Cozy Reads
  4. You’ve analyzed cosy mysteries to a T! The female of the species indeed, haha. And you’re right, some will is at the core of it all, isn’t it? Romantic interest, check. Gossip clubs, check. Now I know what to include in my upcoming bestseller *cough* 😀